The quilt measured exactly 57x75 when I got done, which is what it was supposed to measure. Yay for that. I cut my border strips at 1.75 inches, just like I was supposed to. I put borders on the sides of the quilt, and when I got done, it should have measured 59.5 inches wide, but instead it is measuring 60.5 inches wide now. I can't figure out what's wrong and I'm feeling stymied.
I think I will just fold it up for now and let it sit for a day or two while I mull it over and decide how to proceed.
It's very discouraging to feel like you've done everything right and it comes out wrong anyway. I'm sure somehow I'll figure something out, but I'm worried about the next border, as it is heavily pieced and the quilt needs to be the right size to put them on properly.
Ah well, it is what it is and I will somehow 'Make it Work!'